Questions surround irrigation board water claims

Print Article

The Flathead Joint Board of Control holds 146 water right claims on irrigation project water that were filed in 1982 at the Montana Department of Natural Resources in accordance with Montana water rights adjudication law. Recently the FJBC hired a consultant to address technical issues raised by DNRC, at the request of MT Water Court, on FJBC claims.

But there are many legal questions concerning the FJBC claims that also need to be addressed before the next phase of the Water Court’s adjudication process begins in June 2018 or possibly earlier.

For example, FJBC is listed as the current water rights owner on most of its claims. But does the FJBC have legal authority to own a water right? If not, can the FJBC amend its claims by substituting an alternative owner? What is a possible alternative?

Bureau of Indian affairs also has on file at DNRC claims that are almost identical to FJBC claims. How does the MT Water Court deal with conflicting claims? Will BIA claims take precedence over FJBC claims? If so why?

FJBC claims list the year 1855 as the enforceable priority date. What is the legal basis for this date given that the irrigation project was not developed until the early 1900s?

On FJBC statements of claim, individual properties are listed as places of use. In other words individual irrigator property owners are not directly listed as owners of the water right. What are the implications for those who believe they have a direct claim on project water based on title documents from the US government? What if claims were not filed on such lands by the 1982 filing deadline? Is there a conflict between FJBC water right claims and those who filed a direct water right claim on project water in 1982?

Dick Erb, Moiese

Print Article

Read More Letters to the Editor

(No heading)

March 24, 2017 at 12:18 pm | Lake County Leader Attention irrigators of division one or more commonly known as the Moiese division. As you may or may not know, Dick Erb has resigned his position as the Moiese division representative. As of March...

Comments

Read More

U.S. Attorney thanks state after sudden ousting

March 24, 2017 at 12:18 pm | Lake County Leader It has been my privilege and the highest honor of my professional career to serve as Montana’s United States Attorney since 2009. Over eight years ago, Senator Tester and then Senator Baucus placed t...

Comments

Read More

(No heading)

March 24, 2017 at 12:46 pm | Lake County Leader Remember Dan Rather? Well, his hour long AXS TV “Immigration Report” last week was epic. He shed a great light on why Trump was elected POTUS. Just briefly: In 1965 LBJ signed into law “The Immigrat...

Comments

Read More

Swimmers thank community

March 24, 2017 at 12:58 pm | Lake County Leader We are writing to express our appreciation for the wonderful Montana State Swimming Short Course State Championship that Polson hosted February 24, 25 and 26. We realize what a huge undertaking this ...

Comments

Read More

X